| |
Cinderella
in the Language Arts |
|
Cinderella
Vs. Cinderella |
3rd - 6th grade (for younger students this exercise can
be made an out-loud activity and for older students a comparison between
more than two stories or the genre of Cinderella stories). |
Objectives:
The learner will write a compare/contrast paper. |
On-Line
Resources:
Children's
Literature Web Guide's Cinderella
Contains
a number of links to other Cinderella sites, including a number
of teaching ideas.
Fairy
Tale Encyclopedia - Cinderella
A
brief overview of the story, along with a little history and discussion
of variations. There are a number of good links from this site, as well.
Shen's
Books
This
site describes the elements of a Cinderella story, and contains a
link called "In Search of Cinderella," which offers a list of
countries, leading to Cinderella versions from those countries.
Cinderella
Books from Around the World
A
list of various Cinderella books, although this list is not
categorized by country. |
Other
Resources: various versions of Cinderella, Cinderella:
Oryx Multicultural Folktale Series by Judy Sierra (optional, but
very useful!). |
Procedures:
Use the on-line resources to identify and obtain various versions of Cinderella.
As a class, decide on the characteristics to compare. As the students read the
books, have them identify major characteristics of the story on a
database (or on a graph on paper, if no database is accessible).
Possible fields are listed below - use whichever items are appropriate
for your students. |
Story
|
The
Brothers Grimm's Cinderella
|
Main
Character
|
Cinderella
|
Family
|
father,
cruel step-mother, two wicked step-sisters
|
Main
Character's Wish
|
to
go to the ball
|
Impossible
Tasks
|
pick
out lentils from ashes
|
How
She Attains Wish
|
birds
do as Cinderella bids, magic bird (spirit of her mother?) gives her
gowns and slippers
|
Where
They Meet
|
3-day
festival
|
Animals?
|
birds
who help Cinderella
|
Proof
of Identity
|
the
golden slipper fits
|
Magic
|
birds
help Cinderella & speak to the Prince
|
Important
Person
|
Prince
(some discussion may be necessary here)
|
What
Happens to Evil Characters
|
step-sisters
are blinded by birds (plus they ALREADY cut off part of their feet, so
they have to live with that, too!)
|
|
After the
information is gathered, go over the format for a compare/contrast
paper. A four paragraph format is easiest:
Introduction
| Information about Cinderella in general |
| Information about the first Cinderella story to be compared |
| Information about the second Cinderella story to be compared |
Similarities
| Similarity number one
| Detail, elaboration, or additional discussion of similarity |
|
| Similarity number two
| Detail, elaboration, or additional discussion of similarity |
|
| Similarity number three
| Detail, elaboration, or additional discussion of similarity |
|
Differences
| Difference number one
| Detail, elaboration, or additional discussion of difference |
|
| Difference number two
| Detail, elaboration, or additional discussion of difference |
|
| Difference number three
| Detail, elaboration, or additional discussion of difference |
|
Conclusion
| General overview of similarities and differences |
|
|