About - Taggarts
Row of six colorful ice cream cones. From left to right, red, green pistachio, white, pink strawberry, blue blueberry, and yellow lemon

Ice cream

Vanilla, Chocolate, Coconut, Strawberry, Cookies & Cream, Butter Pecan, Chocolate Chip, Mint Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Fudge, Reese’s, Salted Caramel, White House, Banana, Coffee, Butterfinger. Ask about other available flavors. We make our own ice cream, whipped cream, and sorbet, fresh and smooth. Try them in a dish or on a cake, sugar, or waffle cone. Waffle Cones: extra $1.00

Just a Little Extra

Sliced Bananas $1.10 | Ground Nuts $1.10 | Extra Topping $1.10 | Pecans $1.80 | Spanish Peanuts $1.10 | Brownie $1.55

Image of two vanilla ice cream scoops on top of each other.
Vanilla ice cream, starting from $2.35.

Kid's - One Scoop

$2.35

Small - Two Scoop

$3.10

Medium - Three Scoops

$4.00

Large - Four Scoops

$4.50

Six Scoop Sampler

$6.05

Image of a banana split
Classic Banana Split available for $6.10!

Banana Splits

Old-Fashioned Vanilla, chocolate and strawberry ice creams; chocolate, pineapple and old-fashioned cherry toppings; with whipped cream, ground nuts and a cherry, nestled between two banana halves.

$6.10

Classic All vanilla ice cream; old-fashioned cherry, pineapple, and chocolate toppings; whipped cream, ground nuts, and a cherry nestled between two banana halves.

$6.10

Hot Fudge All vanilla ice cream, lots of hot fudge, whipped cream, ground nuts and a cherry nestled between two banana halves.

$6.10

Image of an ice cream pie
Chocolate Chip Pie available with a caramel drizzle.

Ice Cream Pies

Chocolate Ice Cream Pie Served with hot fudge and whipped cream.

$4.20

Chocolate Chip Pie Chocolate chip ice cream with your choice of toppings and whipped cream.

$4.20

Turtle Pie Chocolate ice cream, caramel sauce, and pecans. Topped with whipped cream and hot fudge.

$5.65

Image of an ice cream pie
Create your own personal sundae in store!

Sundaes

Buckeye Sundae Vanilla ice cream with hot fudge and peanut butter, topped with mini buckeyes and whip cream. Large 6.35 | Small 5.65 | Kids 4.95

$4.95 - $6.35

Pecans Specials An all-time favorite. Vanilla ice cream, your favorite topping, roasted pecans, and whipped cream. Large 6.10 | Small 5.45 | Kids 4.80

$4.80 - $6.10

Turtle Sundae Thus taste treat starts out with vanilla ice cream, caramel sauce, and pecans, then smothered in hot fudge with whipped cream on top. Large 6.35 | Small 5.65 | Kids 4.95

$4.95 - $6.35

Brownie Sundae Vanilla ice cream placed atop a fresh baked brownie, smothered in our homemade hot fudge sauce and topped with whipped cream and a cherry.

$6.00

Order Summary

Qty
Chocolate Ice Cream Pie
$4.20
Medium - Three Scoops (Mint Chocolate Chip)
$5.10
(+$1.10 Sliced Bananas)
Old-Fashioned Banana Split
$6.10
Total Cost
Cart Subtotal
$16.5
Tax
$1.24

Order Total
$17.74